The method
Innocent people jailed, companies taken
The theft of the De Grazia brothers' assets and property follows a method carried out in series: the criminal gang uses the Venezuelan judicial apparatus —special courts with jurisdiction over terrorism, the DGCIM and the SEBIN— to jail the owners and employees of successful companies on fabricated charges, presented to the public as «anti-corruption» actions. The detainees —people innocent of the crimes they are accused of— are held incommunicado for months, subjected to torture and cruel treatment, denied lawyers of their choice and kept without trial for years, in flagrant violation of their constitutional rights. While they remain in that state of defenselessness, their companies are seized and transferred —without any verifiable sale or any consideration— to people close to the criminal structure that governs Venezuela.
The method
The criminal method used to steal the assets and property of the De Grazia brothers can be summarized as follows:
Step 1: Arrest and filing of false charges
The De Grazia brothers were arrested on the basis of three charges that are false and have no basis whatsoever. See the charges and their lack of basis.
Step 2: Incommunicado detention, isolation and de facto kidnapping
From the moment of their unlawful arrest (April 19, 2024) until August 22, 2024, the De Grazia brothers were held at the DGCIM headquarters in Boleíta Norte, Caracas, known as the «Máxima II», a maximum-security facility usually intended for people deprived of liberty who are linked to the military sphere.
There they were subjected to a series of interrogations whose purpose was not to clarify the facts of which they were accused, but to gather information about their assets, including real estate, vehicles, aircraft, boats, commercial structures and financial assets, in order to seize them later by de facto means.
The interrogations of the De Grazia brothers were carried out in flagrant violation of their fundamental rights. They were subjected to coercion, threats and intimidation incompatible with respect for the mental and moral integrity of a person deprived of liberty.
Throughout their time at the Máxima II they were denied the right to the assistance of lawyers. Their material conditions of confinement grew harsher as the days and the interrogations went by, intensifying the physical and sensory isolation to which they were always subjected. They never had access to sunlight or to time in a yard, phone calls were forbidden, and they remained in practically absolute isolation, with no ordinary visual or auditory contact with the outside world.
On August 22, 2024 they were transferred to the El Rodeo I Penitentiary Center, now SESMAS, located in Miranda State, also under DGCIM custody.
In that facility they were, and still are, subjected to a particularly restrictive maximum-security regime, characterized by prolonged isolation, severe limits on contact with their relatives and lawyers, and conditions of confinement incompatible with the respect owed to their dignity as people deprived of liberty. For approximately twenty-three (23) hours a day they are forced to stay in a cell of barely two (2) square meters, and on weekends the confinement worsens, as they spend all twenty-four (24) hours of the day in their cells.
Visits from their relatives, which were allowed only in very limited form after their transfer to SESMAS, take place under strict surveillance. Only their wives or parents are allowed in, one or the other, never two (2) people, who have contact with the inmate through a glass partition and by telephones located on both sides of the visiting booth. The phone communication is recorded and permanently monitored by security officers.
The sworn statements of Carmelo and Daniel De Grazia attest to the above in the first person. Annex 2
Step 3: Pillage, looting of assets, theft of property
While the De Grazia brothers were held incommunicado, step 3 was carried out, basically, in two (2) ways:
- Without formalities. From day one, the DGCIM takes assets «as if it were spoils of war», with no court order or record. See the seized assets.
- With a legal appearance. José Simón Elarba designed «apparently lawful» formulas (sales contracts, share transfers and shareholders' meetings) based on the full inventory of assets that, according to the document, he obtained from the DGCIM. See Bancamiga, Compass Bank and the other companies.
Who benefited
The assets and property stolen from the De Grazia brothers directly benefited ELARBA, his stepson MANUEL FLORES MELO and the DGCIM itself.
The companies were transferred to six recipients: Elarba directly, Velutini, the company Corporación de Tecnología Integral, C.A. (99% owned by Manuel Flores Melo), Flores Melo himself, and two Elarba employees, René Augusto Hernández Giraldo and Aurora Delgado Barrios.
What follows summarizes the «Statement of Facts» submitted by the affected parties. Each claim refers to the annex that supports it where one exists.