The case

The arrest and the charges

On April 19, 2024, officers of the General Directorate of Military Counterintelligence (DGCIM) arrested Carmelo and Daniel José De Grazia Suárez at their homes.

The arrest

That same day, their brother Levin Salvatore De Grazia Suárez turned himself in to the DGCIM on learning that an arrest warrant existed against him. Earlier he had received a call from José Simón Elarba Haddad, a private individual with no public office, who told him he had to surrender and before which military official to do so.

From the arrest until they were brought before the judge, the brothers underwent severe interrogations. Those interrogations did not seek to clarify the facts they were accused of, which they did not know about, but to gather information about their assets: real estate, vehicles, aircraft, boats, companies and financial assets.

The charges and their lack of basis

The brothers learned of the charges at the April 25 hearing. There were three:

The accusation

Charging PDVSA commissions of 15% to 16% on foreign exchange transactions carried out at Bancamiga.

Falsity and groundlessness of the charge

PDVSA did not carry out foreign exchange transactions with Bancamiga. Some PDVSA clients carried out transactions with Criptoexchange Casa de Intercambio, C.A., and that entity carried out exchange-desk transactions with Bancamiga. The commission Bancamiga applied to the exchange-desk transactions carried out with Criptoexchange was 0.15%, that is, 100 times less than the alleged and false commission supposedly charged by Bancamiga to PDVSA, which is absolutely verifiable and demonstrable by reviewing the exchange-desk transactions that were settled at Bancamiga on the date of the investigation.

Since Bancamiga is an entity subject to the control, oversight, inspection and supervision of the State, all of the exchange transactions carried out by Bancamiga were known to SUDEBAN, which in itself makes it impossible that, for example, out of every $10,000,000.00 traded on the exchange desk, Bancamiga charged a false and excessive commission of $1,500,000.00.

The accusation

Operating Compass Bank & Trust without permits to function in Venezuela.

Falsity and groundlessness of the charge

Two official letters from March 2021, one issued by the Ministry of Economy, Finance and Foreign Trade and the other by SUDEBAN, issued after the favorable and binding opinion of the Superior Body of the National Financial System, show that Compass Bank was duly authorized to set up a commercial representative office in Venezuela. Annex 1

The accusation

Conspiring to push up the parallel exchange rate and destabilize the Government.

Falsity and groundlessness of the charge

Bancamiga, through its exchange desk, generated more private supply than most of the other banks at the time of the investigation, and more supply leads to stabilizing or lowering the exchange rate, never to raising it. The gap between the official and the parallel rate was 10% at the time of the arrest, 24% the following year and 32% two years later, so it is not true that the De Grazia brothers conspired to push up the price of the dollar.

Even so, Judge Carlos Enrique Liendo ordered the detention of all three brothers, including Levin, who was neither an employee of nor held any position at Bancamiga or Compass Bank.

The April 25, 2024 hearing

It was held in the early morning, before the Second Special Court of First Instance with control functions, which hears cases linked to terrorism-related offenses, with national jurisdiction and competence to hear and decide offenses related to corruption and organized crime. The hearing is void for two reasons:

  1. The constitutional deadline was exceeded. Article 44, paragraph 1, requires a detainee to be brought before a judge within 48 hours. The brothers were brought in more than 120 hours later.
  2. The right to a defense was violated. They were prevented from appointing private lawyers and a public defender was imposed on them against their will.

Where they are held

The «Máxima II», April 19 to August 22, 2024

They were held at the DGCIM headquarters in Boleíta Norte, Caracas, with no access to lawyers. They never saw sunlight or went out to a yard, had no phone calls and had no contact with the outside world.

In his sworn statement, Carmelo describes isolation in a freezing cell that made him hallucinate, a light kept on 24 hours a day, minimal food rations with a loss of a kilo a day, and the threat of «the tomb», a punishment pit in the basement. When he asked for a lawyer, the guards answered: «Here your only lawyer is God». Annex 2

El Rodeo I (SESMAS), since August 22, 2024

They remain in DGCIM custody under a maximum-security regime. They spend about twenty-three hours a day in a two-square-meter cell and the full twenty-four on weekends.

Only one person at a time may visit them, their wife or their parents, through a glass partition and by telephones whose conversations are recorded and monitored.

Without a defense for almost two years

Carmelo's private lawyers were appointed on May 15, 2024 and filed fifteen requests to be sworn in before the judge. All were rejected, and they were left without an effective and adequate defense until April 20, 2026.

What follows summarizes the «Statement of Facts» submitted by the affected parties. Each claim refers to the annex that supports it where one exists.